My Dying Bride From Inferior to Prime: 3-1

This is my very personal From Inferior to Prime 9-7 feautring the uncrowned kings of all things tragic and miserable. I will list all proper full-lengths of My Dying Bride - that's 12 at the time these lines are written. I don't count "Evinta" as a proper full-length since it is more of an experiment. Naturally, the same rule applies to the two "Meisterwerks", "Trinity", EP's, demo etc.
Here's my personal ode to making miserable music.

#3. For Lies I Sire (2009)

1. My Body, A Funeral
2. Fall With Me
3. The Lies I Sire
4. Bring Me Victory
5. Echoes from a Hollow Soul
6. Shadowhaunt
7. Santuario di Sangue
8. A Chapter in Loathing
9. Death Triumphant

2009 marked the return of the violin in My Dying Bride and I vividly remember how stoked I was when "For Lies I Sire" was about to be released. I did not dissapoint me either, but from what I understand the album seems to be somewhat regarded as inferior compared to the previous 3-4 outputs. I cannot understand why this is since I feel that regardless of the wonderful addition of violin, the songs themselves are very well crafted and the entire album flows like a (dark) river. That is, if one is to disregard from the terrible and out-of-place song that is called "Bring Me Victory". It is a mid-tempo disaster that the band recorded a video to, most likely because it is the shortest track present here. The rest of the songs though, have nothing to be ashamed of and "My Body, A Funeral", "Fall With Me", "Santuario di Sangue" and "Death Triumphant" are true MDB-classics in my opinion.

#2. The Angel and the Dark River (1995)

1. Cry of Mankind
2. From Darkest Skies
3. Black Voyage
4. A Sea to Suffer in
5. Two Winters Only
6. Your Shameful Heaven

For a long time, I held this as my favourite MDB-album ever, but as you can see, I have decided to drop it one place. So what's wrong with it then you ask? Well, except for the incredibly ugly cover (seriously, this is one of the worst official album covers I have ever seen) there's not really anything. It opens with what might very well be the most famous of MDB-songs ever and no matter how tired I am of it - I cannot deny the sheer monumental lurking prescence of misery that "Cry of Mankind" is. It is one of the songs off the album that I listen to the least but the rest of them are equally monumental. This is also the MDB-album where the violin shines the most and where one will find one of my favourite songs ever: "Two Winters Only". If you have the slightest of interest in this band - you have to own "The Angel and the Dark River".

#1. Turn Loose the Swans (1993)

2. Your River
3. The Songless Bird
4. The Snow in my Hand
5. Crown of Sympathy
6. Turn Loose the Swans
7. Black God

My favourite album from My Dying Bride is the same one that a majority of the bands' fans would agree with me on. The monumental doom-metal classic known as "Turn Loose the Swans" is a beyond labelled "just another album". I've already dissected this album earlier - as the Metal Monument that it is - so I'll just end it here. Own it. Love it. Breathe it. This is one of those rare albums that just grow better over time.

My Dying Bride From Inferior to Prime: 12-10
My Dying Bride From Inferior to Prime: 9-7
My Dying Bride From Inferior to Prime: 6-4


My Dying Bride - From Inferior to Prime: 6-4

This is my very personal From Inferior to Prime 9-7 feautring the uncrowned kings of all things tragic and miserable. I will list all proper full-lengths of My Dying Bride - that's 12 at the time these lines are written. I don't count "Evinta" as a proper full-length since it is more of an experiment. Naturally, the same rule applies to the two "Meisterwerks", "Trinity", EP's, demo etc.
Here's my personal ode to making miserable music.

#6. A Map of All Our Failures (2012)

1. Kneel till Doomsday
2. The Poorest Waltz
3. A Tapestry Scorned
4. Like a Perpetual Funeral
5. A Map of All Our Failures
6. Hail Odysseus
7. Within the Presence of Absence
8. Abandoned as Christ
9. My Faults are Your Reward

Hello, I'd like to sort My Dying Bride into 4 different categories:
1. Their death/doom/depressive days from the band's earliest works up to 1995.
2. Their "experimental phase" from 1996 to 2000.
3. Their gothic/doom phase from 2001 to 2008.
4. And finally the return of the violin and all things miserable from 2009 up until the present (2017).
I am not stupid and I realize that many people might not agree with me on this categorization, but I honestly have different feelings towards the bands' albums during different time periods. This would place "A Map of All Our Failures" in the last category and I sincerly feel that the band has gone through some sort of rejuvenation since recruiting the young violinist/keyboardist Shaun into their fold. The violin doesen't weep like it did in the old days, but rather it accentuates the guitars or sets the mood with it's own melodies. This album might not be as depressive as the one that came before it or the one that came after it but it most definitely has a heap of good songs in "Kneel to Doomsday", "Like a Perpetual Funeral", "Hail Odysseus" and "Abandoned as Christ". Also, none of the other songs are forgettable or bad in any way. Overall, this is a very strong effort.

#5. A Line of Deathless Kings (2006)

1. To Remain Tombless
2. L'Amour détruit
3. I Cannot be Loved
4. And I Walk with Them
5. Thy Raven Wings
6. Love's Intolerable Pain
7. One of Beauty's Daughters
8. Deeper Down
9. The Blood, the Wine, the Roses

So, this is basically the last of the "phase-3 albums" (se above for reference) that MDB released. What differs this one from "The Dreadful Hours" (#8) and "Songs of Darkness, Words of Light" (#9) then? Well, I think flows better overall and that there's less filler present here. There is filler as well, namely "Love's Intolerable Pain" and "One of Beauty's Daughters" but that's a minor quibble. I like the fact that after those two lackluster songs, the band chooses to drag us down into complete misery with the marvellous "Deeper Down" and then go into a more experimental (at least for MDB) territory with "The Blood, the Wine, the Roses" which sounds like it was written for "Like Gods of the Sun" back in the mid 90's. Those two, along with "To Remain Tombless" and "Thy Raven Wings" are enough reasons to place this one at number 5.

#4. Feel the Misery (2015)

1. And my Father Left Forever
2. To Shiver in Empty Halls
3. A Cold New Curse
4. Feel the Misery
5. A Thorn of Wisdom
6. I Celebrate Your Skin
7. I Almost Loved You
8. Within a Sleeping Forest

When these words are written (january 2017) this is the latest opus from the ever-dying Bride. After 2-3 listens, this one felt like a letdown after the the bands' two previous outputs, but it grew gradually on me and now I feel that it is a very strong album. What I don't like is the incredibly boring title which just feels tired and clichéd. The album should have been named after the incredible opening song "And my Father Left Forever" which, though also a bit cliché, reeks of actual misery compared to the title track that actually has the word in it. IMO, the opening track is one of the strongest songs My Dying Bride has ever written and the two that follows it are very good ones as well. The title track is cool at first but becomes a bit tedious after time and it has that "Like Gods of the Sun"-feel to it that I like some days and dislike others. Like I mentioned earlier, it is a very strong album overall, even though the band's effort at a "sad piano-violin-almost-ballad(ish) song" in "I Almost Loved You" does not work as well as the classics that is "Sear Me MCMXCIII" and "For my Fallen Angel".

My Dying Bride From Inferior to Prime: 12-10
My Dying Bride From Inferior to Prime: 9-7
My Dying Bride From Inferior to Prime: 3-1


My Dying Bride - From Inferior to Prime: 9-7

This is my very personal From Inferior to Prime 9-7 feautring the uncrowned kings of all things tragic and miserable. I will list all proper full-lengths of My Dying Bride - that's 12 at the time these lines are written. I don't count "Evinta" as a proper full-length since it is more of an experiment. Naturally, the same rule applies to the two "Meisterwerks", "Trinity", EP's, demo etc.
Here's my personal ode to making miserable music.

#9. Songs of Darkness, Words of Light (2004)

1. The Wreckage Of My Flesh
2. The Scarlet Garden
3. Catherine Blake
4. My Wine In Silence
5. The Prize Of Beauty
6. The Blue Lotus
7. And My Fury Stands Ready
8. A Doomed Lover

There's no denying that "The Wreckage of My Flesh" is an über-hit when it comes to all things soul-crushing and bleak. After the opening track, things slowly declines and ends in utter disgrace with the weak song "A Doomed Lover". There are good parts inbetween, such as the majority of "The Prize of Beauty" and bits and pieces off "Catherine Blake" and "The Blue Lotus". Though overall, there is a boring "gothic feel" over this album that does not suite the Bride. Needless to say, the band has always sounded "gothic" on each and every album but there is an overall aura here that doesn't suite the band - "The Wreckage of My Flesh" excluded. Also, that cover-art is so ugly that I automatically squint my eyes each time I witness it's unholy glory.

#8. The Dreadful Hours (2001)

1. The Dreadful Hours
2. The Raven And The Rose
3. Le Figlie Della Tempesta
4. Black Heart Romance
5. A Cruel Taste Of Winter
6. My Hope, The Destroyer
7. The Deepest Of All Hearts
8. The Return To The Beautiful

If "The Light at the End of the World" (#11) was a weak attempt at a comeback after the much despised "34.788%...Complete" (#12) then "The Dreadful Hours" was the true return. From what I understand, it is generally praised among fans as a "true" MDB-record and mentioned in the same breath as the band's earlier classics. So I assume people will generally think I am some sort of MDB-newbie and without a total lack of taste. Well, you people are morons. The reason I place "The Dreadful Hours" so "low" as on #8 is merely due to the fact that I don't find it coherent and there's no real flow on the album. The title-track, "A Cruel Taste of Winter" and "My Hope, the Destroyer" are basically the only songs I listen to on this album. Yeah, the re-recording of "The Return of the Beautiful" is cool I guess, but I really don't see the reason to record it again.
Another reason for the album's placement is that My Dying Bride has so many damn good albums that the internal competition is just too fierce.

#7. Like Gods of the Sun (1996)

1. Like Gods Of The Sun
2. The Dark Caress
3. Grace Unhearing
4. A Kiss To Remember
5. All Swept Away
6. For You
7. It Will Come
8. Here In The Throat
9. For My Fallen Angel

I think that I heard "Turn Loose the Swans" before I "Like Gods of the Sun", but in 1997, this album is what made the teenage me fall in love with My Dying Bride. In retrospect, it very easy to see why. There is no denying that this is the most "accessible" in the band's discography with it's (on average) shorter songs and an overall "hit-lik" feel to many of the songs. "A Kiss to Remember" and "For You" are considered MDB-classics and it's easy to see why. All in all, it is a good album but with a different feel to it compared to many of their other albums - so may even call it catchy at times. I like (not love) most of the songs and they each have something interesting to offer - except "Grace Unhearing" which is a fucking waste of time. I also have to say that "Here in the Throat" might be the band's most underrated track, which I guess is one of the reason my band (ADVERTISMENT!) covered it in 2015.

My Dying Bride From Inferior to Prime: 12-10
My Dying Bride From Inferior to Prime: 6-4
My Dying Bride From Inferior to Prime: 3-1


Retro review: Metallica - ...And Justice for All (1988)

Band: Metallica
Album: "...And Justice for All"
Style: Thrash/heavy metal
Release date: 1988-08-25
Origin: US of A

1. Blackened
2. ...And Justice for All
3. Eye of the Beholder
4. One
5. The Shortest Straw
6. Harvester of Sorrow
7. The Frayed Ends of Sanity
8. To Live is to Die
9. Dyers Eve

The fourth full-length album from Metallica is more or less known for three things:
1. The first album without bass-maestro Cliff Burton and thus, the first album without the "classic" line-up.
2. The absence of bass and it's overall clinical sound.
3. The long, intricate and - by some considered - boring parts in the music.
Since #1 is something that by no means could've had a different outcome on Justice (well, one could argue that had the band decided to skip touring for "Master of Puppets", Cliff would've been alive today, but let's not go there shall we?), I shall look into #2 and #3 a bit further instead.

Regarding the sound, I think it's no secret that producer Flemming Rasmussen was asked by James Hetfield and Lars Ulrich to "take the bass down so you can just hear it, and then once you’ve done that take it down a further 3dBs". The "blame" is to put solely on Metallica's dynamic duo as newcomer Jason Newsted obviously never had anything to say about anything and Kirk Hammett has always been Kirk - just playing what he's told and never questioned anything either. Now I wrote the word "blame" in quotes since I'm not sure whether someone actually should be blamed for it. In 1988, there weren't many albums (if any) that sounded like Justice at all and props should be given to the band for at least trying something different, even if their intentions with the sound was frustration from Burtons untimely demise - one can only guess. Nevertheless, the record sounds cold, bleak and sterile which in my opinion only enhances the negativity in the lyrical theme of injustice and even though I wish I could've heard the bass better, having heard this album so many times over the years, I cannot honestly say that a "warmer" sound more akin to it's predecessor would make it better today. But to be honest, I think that some songs could benefit from a warmer sound. Namely those tracks that are slower and focuses more on heaviness and less on speed - I am mainly talking about "Eye of the Beholder" and "Harvester of Sorrow". All-in-all, I think the sound on Justice doesn't hurt it too much in the end. I mean, it's what we got and in the end it has to do with what the songs mediate and how well they are crafted. Which brings us to the third point of the album.

I understand those saying that some of the songs drag on and on without any point or purpose but I don't necessarily agree. There are songs that have certain parts that drag and at times feels aimless, but those parts aren't very long and they're nowhere near the excess in songwriting that Metallica later would persist having on both "St. Anger" and "Death Magnetic" as well on "Hardwired...to Self-Destruct". Anyway, I will go further into these details as I go through the songs, one by one.

Things begin with "Blackened" - a fast-paced and aggressive opener that - as opposed to it's two predecessors - manages to flesh things out more than "Fight Fire With Fire" did and to be more interesting than "Battery". It is a monster of a song and even though it's gotten it's fair share of love during the years, I feel that it's vastly overlooked and I would even go as far as calling it one of my all-time Metallica-favourites and should respectfully be considered a "true classic" in the same vein as "Creeping Death" and "Master of Puppets". The title-track follows and it's 09:47 minutes is in all honesty a bit too long for it's own good, even though I like the song with it's - for Metallica - odd changes. 2-3 minutes peeled off would probably make the song a lot tighter. "Eye of the Beholder" is only 06:30 long but while the riffs are okay, they're just repeated endlessly which ultimately makes the entire song quite boring to listen to. It feels about 5 minutes too long and I sincerly wish those riffs (especially the verses) would've been saved for a more interesting song. This one could easily be skipped. "One" is without a doubt the most famous song off Justice and it's easy to understand why. It's dynamic shifts between soft and subtle and aggressive and in-your-face is a wonder to listen to. Then add some phenomenal lyrics and it feels like those 07:27 minutes just pass by under a minute. A Metallica-classic if there ever was one.

The second half (at least on vinyl) begins with "The Shortest Straw". It is another fast-paced song that shows no mercy. The chorus is stellar and I have nothing to complain about when it comes to the song-length. But then it comes, the atrocity that is "Harvester of Sorrow"... For some weird reason, this song is considered a semi-classic and many people seem to think that's it's one of the stand-out tracks on Justice. To me, it's 05:44 minutes of pure boredom and the album would definitely have been improved had this song been cut out altogether. It's pointless and tedious and this one definitely drags despite it's short playing time. "The Frayed Ends of Sanity" is 07:44 long and together with the title track, this one could benefit from some trimming. I like it for the mid-tempo oddity that it is, but maybe three verses is just one too much. Yeah, I think so. "To Live is to Die" is an (almost) instrumental track that runs for 09:49 and that is most definitely a running time that's overstayed. Still, I enjoy this one way more than I enjoy it's instrumental counterparts "The Call of Ktulu" and "Orion" from "Ride the Lightning" and "Master of Puppets" respectively. It's heavier and more interesting IMO. The conclusion of the album is called "Dyers Eve" and it's a thrash-fest extravaganza and also the shortest song present here. Nothing to complain about there.

So what can I say? Does the odd production-job harm the album? I cannot lie, I have to answer yes to this question. Mind you, the production is not awful as some people will have you think - it's just different and it does not suit the music 100% at all times. The album feels dark, depressive and angry, which it obviously should considering the death of Burton. Lyrically, I feel it's Metallica's best work ever, ranging from pollution, social injustice, madness, death and the ever-present topic of war. Granted, it is a bit too long for it's own good but don't let people fool you into thinking that it's the same or worse than "Death Magnetic" and/or "Hardwired...to Self-Destruct" - where no quality control regarding song-lengths was present. It may not be as good as "Ride the Lightning" and "Master of Puppets" but it's far more superior than the rest of the band's discography.


Retro review: Guns N' Roses - Use Your Illusion I & II - the ultimate edition

Band: Guns N' Roses
Album: "Use Your Illusion I" "Use Your Illusion II"
Style: Hard rock
Release dates: 1991-09-17
Origin: U.S.A.

Why do a retro review of two albums that are more than 20 years old you ask? Well, in all the reviews I've seen for these two albums, people have always complained about how there are much filler on each of these double-albums and that it would have been better to just release one album with all the good songs. But just really what are the the good songs from these albums? That's exactly what I aim to investigate in this review. With first going through each and every song off the two albums -that's 30 songs all together - and deciding whether they fit my final setlist and then present and evaluate my ultimate collection of UYI-songs. To make things more interesting, I've decided on a maximum of 15 songs and if I'm not entirely sure about a song, it will go in the undecided-pile and battle with another song in the end.
 Everyone onboard? Here we go!

1. Right Next Door to Hell
At the time the album was released, Guns N' Roses was amongst the largest bands on the planet and the anticipation for this album after the successes of "Appetite for Destruction" and "Gn'R Lies" was enormous to say the least. The choice to then place "Right Next Door to Hell" as an opener is questionable to me. It's not that the song is bad or anything, but it's just OK compared to a lot of the other 29 songs. It's a straight-up fast-paced rocker that wouldn't have made the cut had it been ready for the Appetite-sessions a couple of years earlier. I still enjoy it though, but I'm having a hard time trying to decide whether it should be on my ultimate edition.
Verdict: Undecided.

2. Dust N' Bones
A slow moving, bluesy track where Izzy provides lead vocals. Izzy's a cool cat and all but he's no Axl when it comes to the vocals. The song is alright I guess but it's overall mood actually feels distracting from the rest of the album.
Verdict: Nah.

3. Live and Let Die
A cover-song is next up, originally by Paul and Linda McCartney. What can I say, it's boring as fuck and has nothing to do on a Guns N' Roses-album even though it and it's "brother-cover" from the other Illusion (I'll get to it later), are some of the most famous songs by Gn'R. Astonishing if you ask me.
Verdict: Not a snowball's chance in hell!

4. Don't Cry (original)
One of the bands' most known ballads and one that I myself slowed danced a lot to back in my early teens. How does it hold up today then? Well, it feels very 80's* and most rightfully so. In other words, it hasn't aged like fine wine exactly, but as opposed to track #3, it is a classic and a must on the ultimate edition.
Verdict: Yes!

5. Perfect Crime
A fast-paced hard rock attack without any excuses. What could go wrong? Well, it's over almost even before it has begun and that's a complaint from my side. But on the other hand, a longer running-time would've probably made it boring. So there's no excuse not to have this along for the rid.
Verdict: Yes!

6. You Ain't the First
No. Just no. I'm sorry but apart from the very end of the second Illusion - this is by far the most dull song on all the albums. And it's not because I just like the faster songs, on the contrary! But this one has no build-up, no reward and is honestly a weak attempt at a campfire-song that never should've made it onto an actual album, despite it's short track-length.
Verdict: Fuck no.

7. Bad Obsession
This mid-tempo song with it's catchy groove is always a song I've hade a hate/love-relationship with. It's cringe-worthy at certain parts but still I cannot say I don't like it. I don't know why and for now, I'll let it fight it out with another song in the end.
Verdict: Undecided.

8. Back Off Bitch
This is a mid-tempo travesty written by Axl and that dude that more or less forced Slash out of the band. I thought it was crap when I was 13 years old and I think it's crap now - the only thing that is mildly amusing are the "woah-oh-oh-oh's". This song might have been a cool idea for an EP of oddities or something like that but it has no right whatsoever to fill up space on a Gn'R-album in my world.
Verdict: Hell no!

9. Double Talkin' Jive
An amazingly catchy and headbanger-friendly tune. For 1 minute and twenty seconds that is... Then comes one of Slash's most boring solos and then it's all over with that dull fucking fade-out. I don't know.
Verdict: Undecided.

10. November Rain
It's almost 9 minutes long. It's an over-bloated epic with so much pretentiousness that it only could've been written by one mr. W. Axl Rose. And surprise, surprise - it is. I love it, from the beautiful intro with the strings and the flutes, to the emotional vocal-delivery and the crappy rhymes all the way to the superb Slash-solo and the ballsy ending with yet another amazing solo and Axl sounding like only Axl can sound.
Verdict: Most definitely.

11. The Garden
This is a weird oddity. The verses are almost haunting and very effictive in their simplicity. Then comes the chorus with the old fart Alice Cooper and his boring voice. Totally lacks any emotion or feel. When you have one of the greatest vocalists of all time in your band, letting Alice Cooper sing on your song is a stupid idea.
Verdict: Undecided.

12. Garden of Eden
It's a short and quite stupid song, yet I enjoy it's simplicity and ferocious feel. My initial thought was a given on the ultimate edition but when I re-visit it again for the first in a long time, I'm not so sure. Damnit! I have to put yet another song in the undecided-compartment.
Verdict: Undecided.

13. Don't Damn Me
As far as I know, this one has never been played live. A monumental shame if you ask me since I find this to be one of the most (if not the most) underrated of all Gn'R-songs. Ever. It's so damn groovy, the lyrics and vocal-delivery is spot on and it always makes me long for a beer or five when I hear it. Yes, it's simple compared to many of the Illusion-epics but that's what makes it so good. As much as I love the epicness of Gn'R, once upon a time there was only this hard rocking band that had one album in their backpack. What I'm trying to say is, "Don't Damn Me" would've fit like a hammer upon a hamster on "Appetite for Destruction". Hard rock at it's finest.
Verdict: Oh yes!

14. Bad Apples
Along with #11, this is another odd song and it's bluesy feel is not really my cup of tea. The piano grooving is cool and all and there's not anything really wrong with the song, but in the end it's just too weak to be on an ultimate edition album.
Verdict: Nope.

15. Dead Horse
That acoustic intro is wonderful and always fills my heart with a warmth. The rest of the song isn't horse-shit either and even though it doesn't have a part that makes the hair on my arm stand, it wins a lot with it's overall catchiness.
Verdict: Yes.

16. Coma
This 10-minute epic is one of my favourite Rose/Slash-compositions and who could really disagree? It manages to be both catchy and epic at the same time and that slow tempo in the middle of the song always catches me off guard. I love it that we get a new build-up and it's almost like a new song starts even though we instantly recognize it. Alright, I'm blabbering now and should stop. It's a total "yes" from my side.
Verdict: Hell yeah!

1. Civil War
A cherished live-staple for the band as much as it is remembered as ex-drummer Steven Adlers last performance with the band before he was replaced by the human poodle Matt Sorum. It's not a surprise that it became a well-known song for the band, but compared to many of their other "classics" - this one still holds up very well today and is always a joy to listen to. It's not like hearing "Sweet Child O' Mine" for the 1000th time and just want to put a bullet in your head.
Verdict: Definitely.

2. 14 Years
Another quite bluesy and catchy number with lead vocals from Izzy and lots of piano, sort of like a combination between "Dust N' Bones" and "Bad Obsession". I have always had a soft spot for this one, but is it A-material? Not quite sure to be honest.
Verdict: Undecided.

3. Yesterdays
This was a released as a single and I assume it's one of the more known songs from this era. Strange, since it's not a very strong song in my opinion. There's nothing wrong with it but it's just a weaker and more uninteresting song than many others here. I feel kind of sad that it won't be included but I must be strict here and have a maximum of 15 songs.
Verdict: Sadly, no.

4. Knockin' on Heaven's Door
Here it is then, the ugly cover-brother of "Live and Let Die" from the other Illusion, this time it's a somewhat well-known Bob Dylan-track that gets the Gn'R-treatment. While neither cover is performed badly in any way and the band does a good job of making each song sounding like their own, it's just that they're so damn boring compared to so many Gn'R-originals.
Here's my thoughts:
In an optimal world, "The Spaghetti Incident" wouldn't be a boring punk-rock cover album. Instead, it would include "Live and Let Die", "Knockin' on Heaven's Door", "Nice Boys", "Mama Kin" and a collection of the band's other favourites, how about something by Queen or Hanoi Rocks? That would've been so much more interesting.
Verdict: Fuck no!

5. Get in the Ring
When I was 13, this song was the shit. And by that, I mean that I really loved this song. Much was of course due to the profanities uttered which I obviously learned by heart and still today are etched into my backbone. Today, "Get in the Ring" feels more like a half-finished song and a quite pathetic attempt from Axl to make the press seem like the really bad guys and himself like our lord and saviour. No matter how much I adore the man's rock n' roll aesthetics, phenomenal voice and often interesting lyrics - I cannot defend him when he spurts out crap like this.
Verdict: No.

6. Shotgun Blues
Some might lump this together with faster stuff such as "Garden of Eden" and the dreadful "Back Off Bitch" but I disagree. I think it's better than both those songs as it has a rough edge that feels closer to the Appetite-era and works in the same context as "Don't Damn Me" - while not being as good as said song. Difficult wheteher it should be included though.
Verdict: Undecided.

7. Breakdown
Now wer're talking. This is one of the more under-appreciated songs from the Illusion-albums and like "Don't Damn Me" and "Coma" before, there's no doubt in my mind whether this one should be included or not. It's a fantastic track that has so much going and yet it never feels like it's incomplete or distracting. In other words it feels like the band had different pieces that needed to be placed together in order to make sense. In the end, we got a perfectly laid puzzle.
Verdict: Hell yes!

8. Pretty Tied Up
"The perils of rock n' roll decadence". If you take the piano out of the equation, this one feels like it would've been right at home on "Appetite for Destruction" and even the lyrics takes one back to the bands' early days. It's a live-staple and a Gn'R-song that's made classic because of it's merits - not because it's immediately great - but because it's a good song that still holds up.
Verdict: Yes.

9. Locomotive
Some claim this one has elements of funk metal which I find weird and not exactly true. Anyway, along with "Breakdown", it is a long and winding song with many twists and turns and I think that the astute reader by now have understood that I really like those songs. "Locomotive" is no exception and it is a given.
Verdict: Fuck yeah!

10. So Fine
A ballad sung by bassist Duff McKagan in honor of the late Johnny Thunders with lyrics so embarrasing that I'd like to kill myself - does that sound like a keeper? If you answered "yes" - you're dead wrong.
Verdict: No way José.

11. Estranged
Some people claim that this is the finest moment from the post-Appetite version of Guns N' Roses and I am inclined to agree. It works as both a ballad and a monster of epic proportions and towards the middle and end it is so perfect that I remember having tears in my eyes when I heard this song the first couple of times in my life.
Verdict: Abso-fucking-lutely!

12. You Could be Mine
If I remember correct, this was one of the first single from the Illusion-albums and was used to promote a certain little movie called Terminator 2: Judgement Day. It is also in the category of "classics" and was played a lot during the Illusion-tours (and still today). It was written a long time ago, even before "Appetite", but it sounded very "modern" (at least for 1991) and would have sounded out of place on said album. It is a good track but I'm not all fire and flames about it and there are infinitely better songs here.
Verdict: Undecided.

13. Don't Cry (alt. lyrics)
Oh, come on! There's little to no point to include an identical song with different lyrics here. I understand that Axl was satisfied with both versions but this is bordering on idiotic. I remember a friend of mine owning the single with the original, alt. lyrics and demo version of the same song. That in itself just reeks of money-grabbing but to flesh out an already bloated double-album with an identical version is just retarded.
Verdict: No point.

14. My World
From what I understand, Axl and some other dudes (not Gn'r-members) we're quite fucked up on mushrooms when they decided to record this travesty. I guess that's fun and all but to include it on your bands' album without the other members' knowledge and the fact that it sucks donkey balls is something that only Axl can do. Megalomaniacs unite!
Verdict: Of bloody course not!

THE "UNDECIDED" - eight must be four
All in all, there were 8 songs that I didn't know whether they we're right for the ultimate edition. Lucky for me that 8 was the number, both that it was even so 4 could battle against 4 and because I realize I've chosen 11 already and 15 was my roof. So let's do battle!

Right Next Door to Hell vs Garden of Eden
Both songs are quite face-paced and furious rockers. What little advantage Garden... has in forms of lyrics and it's sing-along-factor, is destroyed by the fact that Right Next... is a more fleshed out and "complete" song than it's opponent. An easy victory when I think about it.
WINNER: "Right Next Door to Hell"

Bad Obsession vs 14 Years
Now this one is a lot tougher. Both songs are catchy and neither should be ashamed of it's existance. In the end, I think that the harmonica in Obsession... is a bit too annoying for my taste. It's not that it doesen't fit the song, it's just that I feel they overuse it. Plus 14 Years is a fine example of just how well Izzy's voice can work with Axl's, if he's just given a good song. "Dust N' Bones" is on the other side of the spectrum.
WINNER: "14 Years"

The Garden vs Shotgun Blues
As much as I do enjoy the overall weirdness of The Garden and the fact that it is so different from many of the other songs here, I cannot underestimate the power of Shotgun... It has more twists and turns than what one initially thinks and it's a powerhouse that I feel must be on the ultimate edition.
WINNER: "Shotgun Blues"

Double Talkin' Jive vs You Could be Mine
Now this is difficult. If only Double talkin'... was better crafted, skipped that boring outro and added something worthwhile there instead - it would have been an easy victory. On the other hand, the only real good thing You could... has got going is the part after the second chorus. The chorus itself actually drags the song down instead of lifting it. I am really torn between these two and in the end, I simply took a blind pick. I could've actually gone either way and I'm gonna miss You could... on my final tracklist but rules are rules.
WINNER: "Double Talkin' Jive"

1. Don't Damn Me
2. Breakdown
3. Pretty Tied Up
4. November Rain
5. Right Next Door to Hell
6. 14 Years
7. Perfect Crime
8. Don't Cry (original)
9. Locomotive
10. Dead Horse
11. Civil War
12. Double Talkin' Jive
13. Coma
14.Shotgun Blues
15. Estranged

This was a more difficult task than I first anticipated. Is this the ultimate edition for Use Your Illusion? For me personally, yes it is. Starting with one of the best Appetite-songs that wasn't on Appetite and ranging between soft ballads, hard hitting rockers and epic mastodonts. Sure, the two originals did the same but I believe that the order above is infinitely better and there are no unnecessary hauls inbetween. The decision to end with "Estranged" was of course an obvious one since the ending of the song leaves you exhausted, yet satisfied and is a perfect end to an album. I'm pleased.

As I finished writing these lines, I discovered that there is an official compilation album released by Geffen Records in 1998 simply called "Use Your Illusion". It of course includes the two crappy covers, both versions of "Don't Cry" (sigh!) and oddly enough "You Ain't the First" but no sign of "You Could Be Mine" which I thought would be a given. I guess it's a decent representation of the two albums but it doesn't dig deep enough. Like my "version" does ;-)

* = For those of you too young to remember or those of you that deny the whole, here's the deal:
The 80's as we know it - and by that I mean the fashion, the style, the attitude and much of the music - was born sometime around 1985/86 and died when grunge made it's debut in the mid-90's. In other words, when the two Illusions we're released, we we're pretty much knee-deep in the midst of unholy feathery boas, tight spandex, keyboard overloads, mullets, yuppies and glitter - fact!


Top-7 of 2016

A top-7!? Why the fuck would I only list seven releases from this year you ask? Well, the shameful reason is that I haven't had the time to listen to much new music this year. Work and other minor quibbles (such as life) have effectively gotten in the way. But in my own defense, not many of the bands I listen to have released much new music and even though I'm certain that my list lacks some major releases that I'd probably enjoyed had I heard them, I think it's safe to say that 2016 was nothing compared to 2015, as I still listen regularly to the first 7 of my top-10 list from said year. From this years' list, I can honestly only see myself spinning the first three on a regular basis. Anyway, here's my personal lackluster-list of the dreadful 2016.

7. Dark Tranquillity - Atoma
Style: Melodic death metal
Origin: Sweden
Melodic death metal - I've known you for so many years yet never really cared for you. Well, not really true if you can count At the Gates' monumental "Slaughter of the Soul" into said category. Nevertheless, I've tried to get why people like In Flames but failed, I've always though Soilwork was rubbish and a friend of mine introduced me to Dark Tranquillity in the late 90's. Now while I appreciated the music, it never stuck with me and "Atoma" isn't likely to do so either. But perhaps, just perhaps this album will make me dig deeper into the band's discography. Here's the thing though: DT for me has always been great musicians, interesting and thoughtful lyrics, good artwork, competent vocals (with a sober approach to the dynamics between clean- and growls) and sometimes melodies and hooks in the music that make me raise my eyebrows. The thing is that I never seem to come back to their music. It's honestly a mystery as to why, because just as the case is with Opeth, on the paper I should enjoy the utter fuck out of this band, but I just don't. There's something here that I cannot put my finger on as to why I cannot fall in love with this. Maybe I'm just too old now? Maybe I would have loved this if I actually heard "The Gallery" when it was released in the mid-90's? Hmm.... To be continued...

6. Myrkgrav - Takk og Farvel; Tida er Blitt ei Annan
Style: Black/folk metal
Origin: Norway
I remember back in 2005, when the one-man project Myrkgrav just had released it's demo and was about to unleash it's first full-length "Trollskau, Skrømt og Kølabrenning". The hype was enormous and you could cut the tension with an average-sized black metal-knife. The debut album was released and my reaction was kinda... "Wow - this is great! Well, this is sorta meh... This is alright. Okay. Where's my beer?" Ten years later, the sophomore fare-well album is released and my reaction is pretty much the same. Sure, the vocals are improved and the overall feel of the compositions also feel more coherent. But the thing is that it has been 10 years and although I still enjoy black/folk metal from time to time, my taste in music has changed and I demand so much more nowadays. Had this been released in the early 00's, I would have loved this album utterly, but now I just feel that it's a competent work that lacks that certain magic that I got from the first albums of Otyg, Lumsk and Ásmegin back in the days. Also, four instrumental tracks is at least five too many IMO.

5. Metallica - Hardwired...to Self-Destruct
Style: Heavy metal
Origin: USA
So what can I say that everyone else hasn't already said about the most anticipated metal album of 2016 from the planets' biggest (are they still?) metal band? I can tell you exactly what I feel about each and every song - that's what. The title track could at best be described as boring thrash metal but when James sings the chorus it goes beyond boring and quickly enters the embarrassing territory. But behold (behear?) children! It is by far the worst song off the album and as we enter "Atlas, Rise!" with it's Maidenesqué twin guitar-melodies and mid tempo comfort zone, I feel at home and can relax. "Now that We're Dead" is catchy and leaves a lasting impression even though it's honestly quite dull and almost nursery-rhymelike in it's execution. "Moth Into Flame" could've been the best track on the album due to it's interesting shifts in dynamics and unexpected riffs but those cringe-worthy lyrics cannot be excused. Still, it might be the best song I've heard from Metallica since 1991. "Dream No More" is sort of a mix between "The Thing that Should Not Be", "Harvester of Sorrow" and "Sad But True" - sort of like a combination of the most uninteresting songs from Master, Justice and the Black Album. Though boring, I'd rather listen to this one than the title track but the fact is that Metallica has never been good at making slow, heavy songs interesting and this is no exception. Next up is "Halo On Fire" and while being at least 3 minutes too long, is a competent semi-ballad with some interesting changes and catchy melodies. "Confusion" is a mish-mash of ideas that really shouldn't work on paper but it somehow does. Much of this has to do with some of the best Hetfield-riffs I've heard since 1988. The chorus drags things down but the song never becomes boring and it's one of my favourites on the album. "ManUnkind" is sort of the opposite, a boring rock n' roll-song with a chorus that's gets stuck on one's brain while still being annoying as fuck - impressive! Next up is "Here Comes Revenge" that easily has the best of the videos to any of the songs on the album. Musically, it has some interesting ideas combined with some really dreadful ones. With it's 7.17 minutes in running time, I feel that it could have been a great song with some editing (which can be said about many of these songs). Now it's just good. "Am I Savage?" is the song that I keep forgetting about and there's probably a good reason for that. It's the dullest of mid-tempo-dull I've heard in a long time. It's 6.29 and that's about 4 minutes too long. Now everyone knows that "Murder One" is the tribute to the late god that is Lemmy and lyrically it doesn't try to hide anything. Musically, it has nothing to do with Motörhead though and my initial reaction was a sound "meh...". But for some damn reason, this is the only song on the entire album that actually grew on me. Most of the other songs I could find something really cool or interesting immideatly but this one was just a huge "meh..." and I thought it was a missed opportunity. I don't know what happened with this song, why it grew so much on me, only to become one of my favourites. The closing track "Spit Out the Bone" seems to be everyone's favourite and I too can appreciate the frenzied thrash metal with great dynamics and melodies that it in fact is. But I have to say that it's 7.09 minutes could have been trimmed by one or two minutes and the song would have been even better.

All in all, it's a middle of the road-album to say the least. Yes, I find it to be way more interesting than "Death Magnetic" (2008) and the most coherent and interesting thing the band has done since "...And Justice For All" two decades earlier. But in 2016 I listen to more bands than Metallica and Guns N' Roses (which was the case in the late 80's/early 90's) and the competition is way too hard for "Hardwired...to Self-Destruct" to be able to stick out the way this album would've done in... say 1994. I'm surprised I liked the album as much as I did and I must say that I'm interested to hear what these soon-to-be senior citizens will come up with in the future.

4. Aenaon - Hypnosophy
Style: Avantgarde/black metal
Origin: Greece
The matter of fact that Greece - a completely retard metal country (apart from, let's say Rotting Christ) - could produce something like this is a mystery to me. I read somewhere online that this band was black metal with saxophones and that always makes me interested. Imagine Dødheimsgard without excessive blast-beats, Arcturus' more aggressive parts, a bit of Sigh-insanity combined with coherent and interesting song writing and you're quite close to what Aenaon does. It is progressive and avantgarde black metal with lots of twists and turns, though not as broad as the twists on Arcturus' greatest works in 1997 and 2002. "Hypnosophy" is a great avantgarde/black metal that manges to sound interesting and fresh even though some parts of it aren't thought-through completely. Definitely looking forward to what this band will produce in the future.

3. The Vision Bleak - The Unknown
Style: Gothic metal
Origin: Germany
I must've been high on crack/cocaine when I placed ze Germans in The Vision Bleak on second place on my top list of 2013 with their previous effort "The Witching Hour". It really hasn't aged well if you know what I mean and today, the only track I sometimes listen to is the catchy "The Wood Hag". "The Unknown" is infinitely better and way more thought-through. Sure, there are some lesser songs here such a "Ancient Heart" and "The Whine of the Cemetary Hound" but that is all made for with exceptional tracks such as the heavy-hitting "From Wolf to Peacock", the catchy (and very Tiamatesqé) "The Kindred of the Sunset", the sombre "Into the Unknown" and the dynamic "The Fragrancy of Soil Unearthed" - hell, even the bonus track "The Ghost in Me" is great! The only problem is, if you've heard The Vision Bleak before - you know exactly what to expect. And the band still doesen't come close to their magnus opus "Set Sail to Mystery" (2010).

2. In the Woods... - Pure
Style: Progressive metal
Origin: Norway
Before I get on to the actual music, I want to introduce my readers to a time of yore, to a dark mystic past called.... 1996... or was it -97? I really can't recall.
Anyway, back in 1996/1997 there were five different albums from five very different, yet somewhat alike, bands that really got me hooked on the music I listen to today. Four of those were (in no specific order):
My Dying Bride - Turn Loose the Swans (1993)
Therion - Theli (1996)
Tiamat - Wildhoney (1994)
Moonspell - Wolfheart (1995)
All some of the most well-known albums from each band respectively. And then there's was this odd little gem by a virtually unknown band called In the Woods... and their debut album "HEart of the Ages" from 1995. And yes, that's the proper spelling of the album-title since the band couldn't decide if the album should begin with "Heart" or "Art". Neat. The three dots after the band name is also correct. Moving on...
The only track I actually liked from said album was the epic title track and I still stand by that fact. In retrospective, it's kinda weird that only one song could affect me the way it did. A couple of years later, I discovered the band's second album "Omino" (1997) and that album made me a fan big-time. Around that time, the band had released it's third (somewhat hit-and-miss) album "Strange in Stereo" (1999) and of course chose to disband. Just like most bands do when I discover them. Fast-forward ca two decades and the band is back with what feels like the natural continuation of "Omino". It is avantgarde and weird at some points - yet never weird for the sake of being weird like some bands I listen to (hello Solefald!). Most of the times though, it's very atmospheric and almost Pink Floydian in it's execution - whilst never sounding like said band. When reading these lines, I get that that they make no sense, but perhaps that is for the best since ITW... really doesen't make much sense either. All I know is that I love their music and that "Pure" might be the best comeback I've heard in a long while. The title track, "The Recalcitrant Protagonist", "The Cave of Dreams", "Cult of Shining Stars" and "Mystery of the Constellations" are all great tracks on an album that really doesen't have any weak spots at all. Also, that cover-art is ace!

1. Darkthrone - Arctic Thunder
Style: Black/heavy metal
Origin: Norway
If #2 on this list had the one of the best cover artworks of 2016 - this one might be the absolute worst. It reminds so much of a photo I took with my phone back in 2003. The font of the title is also something that I used to add to my imaginary album-covers I made (don't ask).
Artwork aside, everyone and their mother knows of Darkthrone by now and their status is far beyond legendary in the metal scene. And that's not just the black metal-scene anymore - since the musical transition from black metal into punk/crust/metal territory that began in 2006 with "The Cult is Alive" the band has undergone change after change and their old-school heavy/power metal-album "The Underground Resistance" (2013) was IMO a great album with catchy and fun tunes such as "Valkyrie", "The Ones You Left Behind" and the epic "Leave No Cross Unturned". Now I understand there are many people that shun the band's latter musical pieces and claim that Darkthrone shouldn't be "fun". I get you people as well. I certainly do. I love me some "Under a Funeral Moon" and especially "Panzerfaust" every day as any normal person into black metal. "Transilvanian Hunger" can go and fuck off by the way.
But this is the present after all and while "Arctic Thunder" isn't black metal per se, it might be the closest the band has come to it's classic sound in 10 years or so. To be more precise, it sort of mixes the best pieces of it's predecessor with it's classics. To my ears, this is pure joy to hear and from the opener "Tundra Leach" via the title track to the superb closer "The Wyoming Distance", it is great from start to finish. My only complaint is that there might not be any song that sticks out from the pack. But who can really complain when Gylve and Ted delivers one riff after another that just screams metal? Well, I get it if you complain but I don't. That's the whole ordeal if you know what I mean...


My Dying Bride - From Inferior to Prime: 12-10

This is my very personal From Inferior to Prime 12-10 feautring the uncrowned kings of all things tragic and miserable. I will list all proper full-lengths of My Dying Bride - that's 12 at the time these lines are written. I don't count "Evinta" as a proper full-length since it is more of an experiment. Naturally, the same rule applies to the two "Meisterwerks", "Trinity", EP's, demo etc.
Here's my personal ode to making miserable music.

#12. 34.788%...Complete (1998)

1. The Whore, The Cook And The Mother
2. The Stance Of Evander Sinque
3. Der Uberlebende
4. Heroin Chic
5. Apocalypse Woman
6. Base Level Erotica
7. Under Your Wings And Into Your Arms

I guess it's no surprise that I choose the experimental oddity that "34.788%..Complete" is, as my least favourite MDB-album. The band was going through some line-up changes at the time and the abscence of original drummer Rick Miah and long-time violinist/keyboardist Martin Powell is sorely missed on this album. But that doesn't mean that the album sounds dull in any way. On the contrary, it is a weird thing where no song sounds alike and where very few traces can be found of either the band's past nor it's future. Musically, it is still metal and it you can hear who's behind the microphone, so it's more the lack of violins and the lack of depressive lyrics that are the biggest change. There are hints of doom- and gothic metal here and there but the overall sound is hard to describe in "regular" genres so to speak. While not a bad album per se, it is easily the least emotional MDB has ever done, thus rending it so far from the rest of the band's discography. Some tracks, such as "The Stance of Evander Sinque", "Der Uberlebende" and "Apocalypse Woman" are interesting to hear from time to time but I cannot remember the last time I managed to sit through the entire album.

On an interesting sidenote, the only track that the band regularly has played live from this album is also the least interesting one; "Under Your Wings and Into Your Arms". It is a total waste of time and the one song from this album that I cannot find anything interesting at all about. It's an ok album but it's so far removed from what the band excels at - making miserable music.

#11. The Light At the End of the World (1999)

1. She Is The Dark
2. Edenbeast
3. The Night He Died
4. The Light At The End Of The World
5. The Fever Sea
6. Into The Lake Of Ghosts
7. The Isis Script
8. Christliar
9. Sear Me III

I vividly recall how the band praised this album before it was released and that they've upped the ante and gone back to their roots after the fan-backlash that "34.788%...Complete" was. The growls made their return for the first time since 1994 and we were promised dread, despair and doom. Is that what we got then?

Nah, not really.

For you see, while the songs are (mostly) long doom-metal songs, something is lacking in the song-writing department. I sincerly think this has to do with the fact that guitarist Calvin Robertshaw left MDB shortly after the previous album to work as the band's manager (if I am not mistaken). Anywho, the band certainly tries to find their old formula again but it just doesn't work properly. "She Is the Dark", the title track and "Into the Lake of Ghosts" almost gets there but most of the songs just drag along without any proper direction. This is especially true when it comes to the two songs "Edenbeast" and "Christliar" that just sound like forced attempts at playing doom metal and a far cry from what the band is capable of. Aaron Stainthorpe's growls are also very different from the band's past works and it sounds weaker and less inspired. "The Fever Sea" is an ok attempt at sounding death metal but comes off as quite dull and the less said about the truly awful song "The Night He Died" - the better.

In conclusion, "The Light At the End of the World" is not a bad album (none of them are) either but it does sound dull at some points, ok at other and sometimes forced. It was the first doom/gothic-metal album by the band when they only used keyboards and no violins and sometimes it feels like they are unsure of what to do with the keys, where ex-violinist/keyboardist Martin likely would've come up with some great violin-parts. Shame.

#10. As the Flower Withers (1992)

1. Silent Dance
2. Sear Me
3. The Forever People
4. The Bitterness And The Bereavement
5. Vast Choirs
6. The Return Of The Beautiful
7. Erotic Literature

I guess many of you readers feel it's a shame that I have the band's iconic debut-album so low on my list but again, this has nothing to do with the fact that it's bad or anything. It's just that MDB have released so many other good albums that their humble beginnings of doom just falls behind. After all, the band were young and inexperienced when they entered the fabled Academy studios for the first time to record "As the Flower Withers".

MDB 1992: Ade, Rick, Andrew, Aaron & Calvin
And to be honest, this album is most definitely a death/doom-metal album with very little gothic themes and 99% growled vocals as opposed to, let's say the rest of the band's discography. That makes the album stand out very much and one can hear that they hadn't discovered the true MDB-formula yet - that was something yet to come. Here we have a boring intro, a "classic" tune in "Sear Me" - which is more of an interesting curiousity rather than a great song, then follows MDB's most overrated track ever; the incredibly blatant death-metal failure that is "The Forever People". And then the album really grows with the two epics "The Bitterness and the Bereavement" and "The Return of the Beautiful" with my favourite song off the album placed inbetween; "Vast Choirs" - great and classic doom-metal songs all three of them. Closer "Erotic Literature" is nothing one should care about.

And that's that. Not much else to say than I've already stated; it is a vastly different album compared to the rest of the band's discography and I like it for what it is; a very youthful death/doom-metal album from one of my all-time favourite bands.

My Dying Bride From Inferior to Prime: 9-7
My Dying Bride From Inferior to Prime: 6-4
My Dying Bride From Inferior to Prime: 3-1


Battle Monument: Metallica - Ride the Lightning vs Master of Puppets

Band: Metallica
Album: "Ride the Lightning" vs "Master of Puppets"
Style: Thrash metal/heavy metal
Release date: 1984-07-27 and 1986-02-21
Origin: USA

1. Fight Fire with Fire                   1. Battery
2. Ride the Lightning                    2. Master of Puppets
3. For Whom the Bells Tolls       3. The Thing That Should Not Be
4. Fade to Black                              4. Welcome Home (Sanitarium)
5. Trapped Under Ice                    5. Disposable Heroes
6. Escape                                          6. Leper Messiah
7. Creeping Death                          7. Damage Inc.
8. The Call of Ktulu                       8. Orion

Today, I will be doing a bit of a different Monument-section. You see, I wanted to write something on Metallica and thought whether I should choose Lightning or Puppets as a Monument. But it seemed so dull and predictable and that's when I realized I could compare the two instead. After all, why shouldn't I? Both records have 8 songs and the track order is also very similar to each other. Astute readers may already noticed that I've switched places between "Damage Inc." and "Orion" and the reason for that is obviously that I want to compare as similar songs as possible. Seeing that "Orion" and "The Call of Ktulu" are the instrumental ones this only seemed natural. On a sidenote, I've always felt that "Damage Inc." and "Orion" should have switched places when it was time to release Puppets. Oh, well...

The band that everyone seems to love to hate these days (at least if you're a devout follower of Blabbermouth as I am) was once a universally acclaimed band that could do no wrong. It is difficult to comprehend in this day and age, but there was a time before "St.Anger", "Lulu", failed movie projects and dreadful symphonies when Metallica more or less ruled the metal-universe. And before that, the band was a bunch of teenagers that tried to play as fast as possible which they showed with their debut album "Kill 'Em All" (1983). After that followed what most people seem to hail as the band's best albums; "Ride the Lightning" in 1984 and "Master of Puppets" in 1986. And it seems that the most common belief is that the crowning masterpiece of the band's career is the latter album. I am here to uncover why that is and whether I agree or not.
So without further ado, I say let the unholy battle commence!

Album covers:
 The covers wont be included in the final score, because that would be unfair as fuck if you know what I mean. They're both kinda similar and one doesn't need to be Einstein to understand that they were made in the 80's. Both covers fits it's respective title and overall feel of the album so they're both equally good. But there's really nothing that sticks out and neither had any big impact on me as a kid. In other words - quite the opposite when compared to anything by Iron Maiden during the same era.

1. Fight Fire with Fire vs Battery
Fast opening tracks, both beginning with acoustic guitars. If we I we're to rate them on the intro alone, "Battery" would easily win. It also the most "epic" of the two tracks whereas "Fight Fire with Fire" is more straight-forward and to the point. As an opener "Fight Fire with Fire" wins for me with it's raw fury. Also, I've never understood what is so good with "Battery"? Sure, the riffing is okay but the verses become tedious so fast with what James almost sounding like he's singing a nursery-rhyme. I fucking hate that. In my opinion, "Battery" is one of the most overrated songs in the band's discography and it has nothing to compete with if we're talking the third counterpart-song that is "Blackened". Also, there's no doubt that "We all shall die!" lyrically beats "Cannot kill the family, battery is found in me" by a mile or so.
Fight Fire with Fire

2. Ride the Lightning vs Master of Puppets
In my opinion, one of the best songs that Metallica has ever done is "Master of Puppets". It is an epic track with lots of twists and turns, amazing verses and an equally effective chorus. The interlude is also well written and it never feels as long as it actually is. The song "Ride the Lightning" has absolutely nothing to compete with when up against this monster. The '84 title track has one of the dullest choruses Metallica has ever written and when I listen to the song right now, I only really like the bridge-part where James screams "Someone help me..." etc. Easy win.
Master of Puppets

3. For Whom the Bell Tolls vs The Thing That Should Not Be
"For Whom the Bell Tolls" is the bass-driven monster of a song that made Clifford Lee Burton a well-known name in metal-circles. It is a mid-tempo beast that features some genuinely good songwriting, great vocals from James and bone-chilling lyrics about a man facing his death.
"The Thing That Should Not Be" is also a mid-tempo song and the lyrics are quite cool I guess since they're from H.P. Lovecraft. But that's where the comparisons ends. The latter song is so damn dull it makes it's 6:37 minutes seem like an eternity. Heavy? Yes, slightly but that doesen't help when the verses go nowhere and the chorus makes me yawn. Somewhere in the song, there are traces of what could've really been a great song but to be honest, the entire thing just feels like lazy songwriting compared to so much else we've heard with Metallica. They would do a similar thing two years later with the dreadfully boring "Eye of the Beholder".
For Whom the Bell Tolls

4. Fade to Black vs Welcome Home (Sanitarium)
This is actually the first song-battle where things become really difficult. Both songs are semi-ballads with lots of acoustic guitars and mellow verses. "Welcome Home (Sanitarium)" has a chorus that is slowly being built up to and then goes all heavy. "Fade to Black" lacks a proper chorus but has a part that almost could be a chorus that also have slowly been built up to prior. I can't help but feel that "Fade to Black" feels a bit more "epic" even though they're quite similar in length and let's not forget the amazing ending to "Welcome Home (Sanitarium)" starting from the part where James sings "Fear of living on...". That part alone is fucking amazing!
All in all, both songs are great and even though they're similar to one another they manage to be different as well. If I was forced to choose - which I am right now - I'll go with "Fade to Black" since it is amazing from start to finish, whereas the other one is just "great" from beginning to middle - then it becomes amazing.
So far, it's 3-1 for the '84-record and things look grim for "Master of Puppets".
Fade to Black

5. Trapped Under Ice vs Disposable Heroes
Ouch, this is another difficult one. "Trapped Under Ice" is a thrash-metal anthem on it's own merits and even though I hate the guitar-solo in the beginning, the verses are ace, the chorus is stellar, the bridge is great and Lars' drumming is some of the best during his entire career. On the other side of the fence we have "Disposable Heroes", a song that is twice as long, much more epic, more twists and turns and arguably more interesting lyrics. If I had a hard time choosing a winner in battle #4 - it is nothing compared to what I had this time. Ultimately, the victory goes to "Disposable Heroes", but it is by the slightest margin.
Disposable Heroes

6. Escape vs Leper Messiah
Once more a tough battle ahead. This time it's due to the fact that we are arguably dealing with the least good songs on each album. Everyone knows Metallica wrote "Escape" as a potential radio-hit but nothing ever became of it. The song is sort of fast mid-tempo I guess which sounds weird but actually makes sense if you listen to it. There is nothing wrong with the verses whatsoever and I like the pacing. The chorus is a bit cringe-worthy though and I totally get why this song recieves so little love from both fans and the band. But the part with "See them try to bring the hammer down..." is cool as fuck!
On the other hand, "Leper Messiah" has no excuses as it wasn't written to please a wider audience. It is not a very exciting song but it isn't bad either. It's a cool mid-tempo verse with a boring pre-chorus and a chorus that is ok. And as usual, the song really picks up a lot when it's time for the bridge. It's weird that I find so many Metallica-songs that I consider quite "weak" have so many damn good bridges which just makes the hair on my arms stand straight up. Both songs are ok - nothing more, nothing less - but it would be fault by default if I didn't give the victory to "Leper Messiah".
Leper Messiah

7. Creeping Death vs Damage Inc.
Let's just get it over with ok? "Damage Inc." is a good song. A fast thrasher that has nothing to be ashamed for. It's lyrics might not be the best penned down by Hetfield but who cares when a song is this good! BUT... "Creeping Death" is the best song ever written by Metallica. Period. Amazing verses, amazing choruses and perhaps the best bridge I've ever heard in my life. End of story.
Creeping Death

8. The Call of Ktulu vs Orion
So, we're at the final battle and the two instrumental songs. The score is 4-3 to "Ride the Lightning" so "Orion" really has to win this if "Master of Puppets" shall remain the undisputed king. The tension is thicker than fog. Or not. Here we go

I rarely enjoy instrumental tracks whatsoever. The only two exceptions are tracks I've already ranted lots about on this blog earlier - namely "Perverse...Almost Religious" by Moonspell and "La Masquerade Infernale" by Arcturus. Both are short tracks, leaning heavy on keyboards and atmosphere alone. Both these Metallica-songs are long, droning tracks over 8 minutes each with just guitars, bass and drums. This cannot end well...

"The Call of Ktulu". It has a nice build-up and when the song goes heavy it's still sounding damn good! Then, nothing happens... After 2½ minutes I am already a bit bored and we still have more than 6 minutes to go. Kirk tries to do some fancy wah-wah stuff and Cliff also does what he can with his bass-wizardry but when the rythm goes on and on the same way for fucking forever - what little salvage is there left? The guitar solo in the middle of the song doesen't help either - I just want it to end.

"Orion" begins spooky as hell and I like that creeping feeling it evokes. When the heavy guitars begins, it sounds just like a verse to a regular song - such a shame that there are no vocals present. When something finally changes (after way too long) it is cool as fuck and I find myself nodding my head along to the music. Wouldn't you know it? Here comes Hammett with another boring guitar solo that tries to hide the fact that we've heard the same boring chugga-chugga verse from James for an eternity. Compared to "The Call of Ktulu" this one changes completely somewhere in the middle of the song and even though it's not the best thing I've heard from this band it is refreshing just to hear something new. But what in the holy hell are the lead guitars doing at 05.15!?? It sounds like Kirk is playing a lullaby or something. It is completely wrong for the song and just feels like he's playing what he's feeling at the moment. More soloing and more chugga-chugga. Sigh...

I am having a really hard time to pick a winner for this final battle and it's dissapointing that I had to end with the most boring parts from each records. Oh, well. After much consideration "The Call of Ktulu" somewhat unexpectedly wins. At least it is consistent and fits the album, unlike "Orion".
The Call of Ktulu

Ride the Lightning 5 - 3 Master of Puppets

End ramblings:
And that means that "Ride the Lightning" is our winner. When I first started to write at the top of this blog-post, I was certain that this would be case. Then I started writing and the score became 4-4 as I thought "Orion" would win easily over "The Call of Ktulu" which wasn't the case at all (I hadn't heard either song in a long time mind you). On a sidenote, I find "To Live is to Die" to be Metallica's strongest instrumental track. Also, I first had "Trapped Under Ice" as a victor over "Disposable Heroes" but when I re-visited the latter song I realized how much stronger it is.

However, it was extremely tight between the two albums and I think they're both Monuments and worthy of their places in metal history. As I mentioned in the beginning, both albums are very similar but I get why "Master of Puppets" is hailed as the better of the two. Hetfield's vocals are stronger, all the instruments are tighter, the songs are more complex and the production is vastly superior. But sometimes I feel like the complexity goes too far (hello "Orion"!) and I love the simplicity of "Fight Fire With Fire". Furthermore, I like the crudeness of Hetfield's voice on "Ride the Lightning", I like how the playing sometimes isn't top notch (though mostly it is) and I find the slightly "colder" production fits the album like a glove. But above all, it has so many good moments on so many songs. If I were to pick stand-out moments on each album (I wont though, since we would be here all day) - I am certain that "Ride the Lightning" would win easily. For me that is. You're free to think that "Master of Puppets" is the better of the two. But you're wrong.

"Crystallized as I lay here and rest

Eyes of glass stare directly at death

From deep sleep I have broken away

No one knows, no one hears what I say"